“charlesʼs wain” (MS III; Poems [1891]; Works [1903])—Noting
the reference to
Charlesʼs Wain,
Helen Gill Viljoen
(
“Viljoen Papers”,
box F.X) remarks that
Ruskin could have learned the constellations from
Jeremiah Joyce
(
Joyce, Scientific Dialogues, ) or from
Thomas Day
(
Day, Sandford and Merton, ). For
Ruskinʼs interest in this constellation, see also “Harry and Lucy”, Vol. 2, chap. 1; and “The
Constellations: Northern, Some of the Zodiac, and Some of the Southern”.
Between lines 24 and 25—The Library Edition incorrectly identifies John James Ruskin as adding the date 9 September 1826.
The hand, which is certainly Margaret Ruskinʼs, is identical to that for a similar annotation in MS I.
“[lost]” (Poems [1891]; Works [1903])—W. G. Collingwood
comments that the “word in square brackets”, which he supplied, “is wanting in the original”
(
Poems [4o, 1891], 1:xxv;
Poems [8o, 1891], 1:xii).
In the sole extant manuscript version, there is no evidence of such a word existing.
Collingwood assumes
Ruskinʼs intention,
since, without the word, the second line in the stanza would deviate from the “abab” rhyme scheme that prevails throughout the remainder of poem.